End of an Era

The bear hierarchy is fluid. Bears jostle constantly within it, gaining and losing rank as they grow into adults and age into older bears. In 2017 at Brooks River, one bear has asserted his dominance over all others in ways he’s never done before. There appears to be a new dominant male on the river and he’s known as 32 Chunk.

bear standing in grass

32 Chunk in early June 2017. Photo courtesy of Katmai National Park.

In 2011, I began recording interactions between bears at Brooks Falls, noting who displaced who, who avoided who, and which bears were courting, stealing fish, and playing together. Out of hundreds of interactions I witnessed, one bear was consistently and clearly dominant over all others, 856.

bear standing in water

856 stands in Brooks River on June 30, 2016.

From 2011 to 2016, 856 wasn’t displaced once. I only noted him yielding on very rare occasions, like when he faced a particularly defensive mother bear. No other bears even seemed to challenge him. 856 ascended to the top of the hierarchy rather quickly in 2011, outcompeting other large males like 814 Lurch and 747, and for many years remained the river’s most dominant bear.

two bears facing each other in water

856 (right) displaces 747, another large adult male bear, from the jacuzzi in 2013.

Life at the top of the hierarchy is difficult, however. Other bears are subordinate, but not subservient, to more dominant animals. If injury, illness, or age weakens a dominant bear then others will not hesitate to usurp their position, gaining greater access to food and potential mates. Other bears, often younger and stronger, are more than willing to take your spot if given the opportunity.

In the video above, 856 is the bear in the jacuzzi (the plunge pool below Brooks Falls) while 402, an adult female, stands on the lip. Notice how 856 turns to face the bear approaching from the far side of the river. This is 32 Chunk.

Screen shot from video. Three bears near a waterfall. Text reads "402," "856," and "32 Chunk."

856 backs out of the jacuzzi to avoid 32 Chunk. He then goes to the lip where 402 stands, but 32 Chunk follows. Above the falls, 856 makes no attempt to challenge Chunk. 856 stands and watches as 32 turns away from his competitor, like dominant bears are apt to do, and walks out of the frame.

Generally, when two bears of approximately the same size and disposition meet for the first time, both bears posture openly as they evaluate each other’s size and the potential to do physical harm. 856 yielded quickly and readily to 32, so they have encountered each other before the video above was recorded. During a previous encounter 32 Chunk may have asserting his dominance even more clearly, hence 856’s willingness to yield. 856 simply saw 32 approach and instantaneously realized he could not challenge the larger 32, so he backed away to avoid picking a fight he probably wouldn’t win. (Many, if not most, interactions between bears are like this. They are defined by avoidance.)

bear standing in water and facing the right side of the photo

32 Chunk in 2014, while he ranked in the middle of the bear hierarchy for adult males.

Nature abhors a vacuum. No niche is left unfilled within the bear hierarchy. 856, perhaps weakened by injury or age, appears to no longer be the most dominant bear at Brooks River. His younger competitor sensed weakness and exploited it. This isn’t a contest of longevity though. During his time as the most dominant bear, 856 had free reign over the best fishing spots and went unchallenged for access to females in estrus. For years, he grew large and strong, probably siring more than one litter of bear cubs along the way. Now 32 Chunk (and possibly other bears like 747) hold those advantages.

856 remains a large bear and his size will continue to allow him great access to fishing spots at Brooks River. Bears grow up quickly, gaining the strength and skills necessary to survive a harsh, competitive world. Eventually though, the competition catches up.

21 thoughts on “End of an Era

  1. That video was very telling. Chunk literally made himself clear that he is the Big Boss Bear of 2017. Looks like he took off in pursuit of 402 and left 856 standing there. Not sure when that video was shot but it does looked like his injury is improving. His movement didn’t seem too impaired. Perhaps the presumed death of Lurch, the absence of 747 from the falls this year attributed to Chunk’s rise this year. He saw the opening and moved in


      • No worries. I made the edit. I do think Chunk’s ascendancy to the top was very much influenced by the absence of 747 and 814 this year. 747, I presume, is still wandering out there somewhere, but without him at the falls, there is no other bear who is large enough to compete with Chunk right now.


  2. Thanks, Ranger Mike, for this helpful post. I’m glad that you took time to note — and help us understand — this important historical moment.

    FWIW: It saddens me to see the once-dominant 856 now less confident in front of the other bears — especially since he’s so much larger than many of them. (I know that my feelings about this don’t matter — just wanted to acknowledge them anyway.)

    It’s been fascinating to watch 32 Chunk’s behavior change this year — now that he’s on top of the heap and has to demonstrate his dominance on a regular basis.

    I look forward to seeing how 856 adjusts to his new role in the heirarchy — especially as his injuries improve.

    Thanks, as always, Ranger Mike, for helping us understand the bears.


  3. Pingback: Bear Cam Week in Review | Explore

  4. Pingback: There is no average bear | Wandering at Large

  5. Pingback: Bear Cam Week in Review September 22 | Explore

  6. Pingback: What to Look for 2018: The Bear Hierarchy | Explore

  7. Pingback: Huge brown bears complete for dominance on live Alaska webcams

  8. Pingback: Huge brown bears complete for dominance on live Alaska webcams

  9. Pingback: The brown bears of Alaska’s bear cam are already fighting for dominance – Daily News and Deals

  10. Pingback: The brown bears of Alaska's bear cam are already combating for dominance | Tech News

  11. Pingback: The brown bears of Alaska’s bear cam are already fighting for dominance – My Blog

  12. Pingback: Huge brown bears complete for dominance on live Alaska webcams - Top News Top Videos

  13. Pingback: The brown bears of Alaska’s bear cam are already fighting for dominance – Buzzabe.com

  14. Pingback: El día 2 de la Semana del Oso Gordo enfrenta a un poderoso y marcado hombre contra un joven retador. – RD Test

  15. Pingback: Day 2 of Fat Bear Week pits a scarred, powerful male against a young challenger | ADMK Agency

  16. Pingback: 2019's baddest, most dominant bear cam bear has emerged | WorldNews | Travel Wire News

  17. Pingback: The baddest, most dominant bear cam bear has emerged in 2019

  18. Pingback: 2019's baddest, most dominant bear cam bear has emerged

  19. Pingback: Early September Bearcam Questions and Answers | Wandering at Large

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s